• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Mackie's Pizza - Authentic Thin Crust & Deep Dish Pies in Harrisburg, IL

Mackie's Pizza in Harrisburg, Illinois, is a local gem known for its consistently delicious pies and welcoming atmosphere. Their standout offerings include a crispy thin crust pizza with a bold, robust sauce and a richly flavored deep dish featuring a lightly sweetened Italian marinara. Customers rave about the perfectly melted cheese and the unique sweet sauce served alongside their cheesy bread. The quality and flavor remain reliable over the years, making Mackie’s a must-visit for both locals and travelers. Whether you prefer thin crust or deep dish, Mackie's delivers satisfying, memorable pizzas that honor true Italian-American tradition.

Mackie's Pizza at a glance

  • Address 502 E Poplar St, Harrisburg, IL 62946, United States
  • Phone +1 618-252-6368
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Mackie's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Ryan Fisher
5

Mackie's is my favorite restaurant in Harrisburg. 2 district different pizzas; a grea, crunchy thin crust with robust sauce, and a deep dish with sweet sauce. Both are great in my opinion.

Dean Ehrenheim
5

After a long day of cabin projects I was treated to dinner at Mackie’s. I have driven by this place many times and never considered stopping. But now, it will be hard to pass without a stop. Some of the BEST pizza I have ever had. We ordered thin crust pepperoni and specially asked for the sweet sauce. The crust was crispy, cheese melted perfectly and the sauce was out of this world. We also got the cheesy bread - great. It comes with a side of the sweet sauce. Now before you think “sweet” as in candy, no! Lightly sweetened Italian marinara sauce. Outstanding. If you travel through or even near Harrisburg (or Marion, IL) you owe to yourself to get a pie and try it!

Scott Smith
5

I've eaten at Mackies most of my life, let's just say many years. The one amazing aspect is the taste is consistent each and every time!! I can't say that for almost any other restaurant we ever eat at. Great friendly people each time as well. I would highly recommend their Pizza if you're in the area. It's a drive for us but we'll worth it!!

Nick Sharon
4

Out of towners came to hike and decided to explore a local pizza spot. We were more then impressed. We thoroughly enjoyed the garden deep dish which had surprising flavors!! Definitely recommend supporting this tasty local joint!

Pete Herren
4

It was a nice little pizza joint. Nothing fancy, but clean and the pizza was good. We shared a pizza and spent about $25, but we did not get drinks.

Clay Burns
5

Really good thin crust Pizza! But the cheese garlic bread with the sauce is why I love this place! So simple yet so delicious!!!

Location

  • Mackie's Pizza
    Mackie's Pizza
    502 E Poplar St, Harrisburg, IL 62946, United States Hotline: +1 618-252-6368

Mackie's Pizza, located in Harrisburg, Illinois, is a standout destination for pizza lovers seeking authentic and consistently delicious flavors. This local gem has built a loyal following thanks to its expertly crafted thin crust and deep-dish pizzas, each boasting distinctive and robust sauces that elevate every bite.

One of the highlights at Mackie's is their thin crust pizza, praised for its perfect crunch and bold tomato sauce, delivering a balance of texture and rich taste that keeps customers coming back. The deep-dish option offers a contrasting experience with a lightly sweetened Italian marinara sauce that adds a subtle, savory sweetness without overpowering the overall flavor profile. This sweet sauce is also served alongside their delectable cheesy bread, making for a compelling appetizer or side.

Beyond the food, the atmosphere is straightforward and inviting—no frills, but clean and friendly, creating a comfortable environment for enjoying a meal. The staff's warmth matches the pizza’s warmth, adding a personal touch that enhances the dining experience.

What truly strikes me about Mackie's Pizza is the remarkable consistency of flavors over time, a rarity among eateries today. Whether you're a local or just passing through Harrisburg or nearby Marion, Mackie's offers a genuine taste of Italian-American pizza that is worth seeking out. The careful attention to sauce, crust, and cheese melds tradition with a unique twist, ensuring every pizza served is memorable.

In summary, Mackie's Pizza delivers on authenticity, consistency, and flavor depth in a clean, welcoming setting. For anyone searching for a reliable, tasty pizza experience with a distinctive local touch, Mackie's Pizza stands as a must-visit.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • On-site services
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards